The Ins and Outs of SharePoint Check Out
How does check-in/check-out functionality relate to versioning?
When people think of check-in/check-out functionality in SharePoint, they often conflate it with versioning. While both are core features of SharePoint’s document management capabilities, they are distinct settings.
Check-in/check-out functionality ensures that only one user at a time can edit a document. To begin editing a file, users must first check it out. When finished editing, users must check the document back in before other users can view the changes or check it out to make their own edits.
Versioning, on the other hand, is the setting that allows you to track the history of a document by saving new versions when changes are made. Versioning does not require check-in/check-out, and check-in/check-out does not require versioning, but using both together gives you even better control over your documents than using one of these features alone.
Benefits of check-in/check-out:
Prevent conflicting versions
Checking out a document locks it for editing by other users. This prevents users from making changes simultaneously, which would create competing versions of the document. Users don’t have to worry about someone else overwriting their edits.
Control when versions are created
New versions are only created when a document is checked in. Users who are working on a document can save their changes without checking it in, giving them flexibility to save their work-in-progress without publishing the draft for others to view. This also helps you control the number of versions that are created. Without check-in functionality enabled, new versions will be created each time a user saves, no matter what changes were made since the last save. This can leave you with a rapidly growing number of versions that have only minute differences between them. Check-in functionality makes creating a version a more conscious decision.
Add comments to the version history
Check-in comments create an ongoing historical record of the changes that were made in each version of the document. Each time a user checks in a document, they have the opportunity to add comments about that version, which makes it easier to find a particular version if you later need to view or restore a previous iteration. To make check-in comments more prominent, we recommend adding the Check In Comment column to your default library view.
When should you not use check-in/check-out?
If you rely on real-time collaboration of documents, you should not require check-out. From SharePoint 2013 onwards, SharePoint has offered the ability to co-author documents. Co-authoring allows multiple users to collaboratively edit the same document at the same time, similar to the simultaneous editing functionality available in tools like Google Docs. Check-out functionality is incompatible with co-authoring, since only one user at a time can edit a checked-out document. So you will need to decide which document collaboration style makes more sense for your needs, and configure SharePoint settings appropriately.
How do you require check-out in SharePoint?
By default, document libraries do not require check out of files. Users can still check out files if they choose to, but most users are unaware that they can or should. So how do you require users to use check-in/check-out in SharePoint? You can configure this setting for individual libraries by going to the Require Check Out section of the library’s Versioning Settings. Once you’re there, it’s as simple as selecting the “Yes” radio button!
What else should I know about check-in/check-out?
Check in files promptly
Check in your documents once you have finished making updates. Otherwise, other users won’t be able to see your changes or edit the file themselves. Also keep in mind that when you create or upload a new file, that file will automatically be checked out to you. Remember to check it in so that other users can access the file.
You also have the option to discard your check-out. If you checked out a file, but ultimately decided not to make any changes, you can simply discard your check-out instead of checking in a new version of the file.
Don't forget about metadata
Changes to properties/metadata require check-out. When uploading a new document to a library that has required metadata, you will have the opportunity to add the appropriate metadata before checking the file in.
Override check-outs when necessary
Let’s say that one of your co-workers goes on an extended vacation, and you need to edit a document that is checked out to them. The document will be locked for editing, and you will not be able to check it out. What can you do? In cases such as this, site and library administrators can discard that user’s check-out. This will revert the document to its pre-checked-out version and allow you to check it out for yourself. Just be aware that any changes your coworker made will be lost, so this should be done with caution. When your co-worker returns to the office, they may want to reconcile the changes made in their local copy with your new version of the document.
Check-in/check-out imposes a more rigid procedure for document editing than some companies and employees may be used to, so it may not be appropriate for every use case. But if collaborative editing has turned your document libraries into the Wild West of SharePoint, this structured way to manage changes may be just what you need. Especially when used in conjunction with versioning, check-in/check-out gives you more granular control over document versions.